A Bag of Gold

I really liked Gardner Campbell’s “No More Digital Facelifts” talk that was recommended watching for #ds106 (embedded below).

I like it enough that I decided to remix it. I don’t claim to have captured all, or perhaps any, of the spirit/content of Gardner’s talk but it was an interesting experiment and hopefully one that entertains a few people. If anything it should encourage you to listen to the actual talk. It really is good and I don’t like talks.

bag of gold

Limitations

I limited myself to the length of the instrumental (Nas – If I Ruled the World)
I limited myself to under an hour of editing.

Some Notes on Process

I chose the Nas song after browsing around looking for instrumentals that were titled something to do with gold and being unhappy with what I found. One easy way I use to get a feel for a good song is to set the audio of the speech playing and then browse for music. That way, when I preview various songs, I’m hearing the voice over the music like I would in the final product.

I did all the editing in GarageBand. I tend to cut up the speech as I listen and pull clips that I especially like into a different track. Once I’ve got them there I drag them over the music and start to shuffle things around. It’d be nice if I could separately label the diced up pieces but if you can do that in GB, I don’t know how.

Yes, that is Jim Groom laughing hysterically in the audience.

Comments on this post

  1. I love the chorus,
    “This is a bag of gold, what part of that do you not understand?”

    So brilliant, and now you have Grant Potter mixing it all up—how awesome is this. You’re out of your mind right now Tom, ride that wave. The art is a flowing.

    • Gardner has just the right level of anger in his voice when he says that. Clearly, I love that line.

      Grant’s remix is perfect. You’ve gathered some really cool people together for this. Hats off to you for that. It’s going to be an interesting ride.

      As a side note, I stole that “Digital Facelift” assignment for my instructional tech class. They will be responding via blog and letting me know how that idea impacts what they plan to teach in k12. It’ll be interesting to see what non-ed tech people think of that.

  2. I can nenver get enough of this talk by Gardner, and setting it to music suggests what a song writer Gardner really is when it comes to presentations. And this is the favorite I have heard from him, and there is an edge to the presentation that makes it that much more powerful, and like you note, it is all in the tone of his voice.

    As for Grant Potter, he is totally awesome, and he will be at NV (at least I think he will) and he jams even harder in person.

    Looking forward to your students reactions, are you gonna feed there work in ds106? Or at least select parts of it?

    • NV is a siren song. I have wanted to go for some time. If I can get funded I’m there.

      We’ll see what the students say. It’s a little far out for them based on what I know of the rest of the program. I’ll likely invite comment from the #ds106 field.

  3. Oh man, the cut of of old beat days remastered and placed in a more shareable space without the press or ink or tree
    not better in construction, just different and viewable readable sharable too and mashable

    beautiful
    Ginsberg would smile and the pranksters would giggle and grin
    perhaps begin to speak
    and we could capture the minutes moments and splash them on an audio canvas
    and spit them out to the You
    Tube if television or iPod

    beautiful.

    • Appreciate that Todd. We’re going to have to start setting your comments to music if you maintain that level of poetry. :)

  4. Tom, this is genius. I love it. I was in the room for Gardner’s presentation, and this version captures it so well.

  5. also, I can neither confirm nor deny that this file has found its way onto my iPhone for addition to the shuffle playlist.

    • Now that is a true compliment . . . and it makes me feel better about what may or may not be own decision to do the same.

  6. Tom – your work has motivated me to take things up a notch – really looking forward to the coming weeks.

    I can confirm that by hook or by crook I will be throwing down for NV2011 – wouldn’t miss it for anything.

    • ditto, on both fronts. I’ll be at NV011 if I have to start walking now.

    • Why do all cool conferences and people tend to be in Canada or Australia? I’m going to have to pitch the idea to the powers that be, despite their mandates forbidding out of state (no mention of out of country though . . . ) travel.

  7. Oh hells yeah – this is quality.

  8. This is awesome. Oh no…another currency to master 😉

    • Noise Prof and Jabiz – Gardner is the man and Nas is not too shabby either.

  9. This is really good. This sound can be a pluging for everything no matter the situation.

  10. Loved this! Terrific idea to do and just shines a light on how “made for the stage” Gardner really is. I recently put together a comic homage of Gardner’s “bag of gold” talk: http://robinscomics.posterous.com/40605490
    Thanks for bringing it to us in a new way.

  11. Years later, in 2014, Gardner’s presentation still rocks the house, and so does your mp4. Thanks for creating and sharing.

    • Gardner is the man. No doubt. I now get to work with him at VCU which is all kinds of fun.

Leave a Reply

Trackbacks and Pingbacks on this post

  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Gardner Campbell. Gardner Campbell said: RT @grantpotter: RT @twoodwar: Remixed @gardnercampbell's "Digital Facelift" talk for #ds106 http://bit.ly/dM9Yaq >> Fantastic – … […]

  2. […] haven’t checked out Tom Woodwar’s remix of Gardner Campbell’s #opened09 talk “No More Digital Facelifts” do so now before you […]

  3. […] haven’t checked out Tom Woodwar’s remix of Gardner Campbell’s #opened09 talk “No More Digital Facelifts” do so now before you […]

  4. […] carving out a domain of one’s own and its implications for teaching and learning, check out Tom Woodward’s Remix of the talk, along with Grant Potter’s remix of Tom’s remix Not to mention Lisa Lane’s […]

  5. […] same subject and two of the other responses to it. If you haven’t heard Tom Woodwar’s remix of the presentation and Grant Potter’s remix of the remix, you should totally go there RIGHT […]

  6. […] Woodward’s remix of Gardner Campbell was great and missed epicness by the slimmest of margins.   What was missing […]

  7. […] Lisa Lane made an excellent post summarizing and reacting both to Professor Gardner Campbell’s short article titled “A Personal Cyberinfrastructure and his thought-provoking presentation at the 2009 Open Education Conference called “No More Digital Facelifts: Thinking the Unthinkable About Open Educational Experiences”, which Tom Woodward brilliantly remixed in audio. […]

  8. […] dropping out, but I keep getting pulled back by Jim Groom's enthusiasm (er, madness?), the lure of Gardener Campbell's bag of gold, and all of the shiny nuggets feeding into the DS106 space. No doubt that each week is going to be […]

  9. […] read the article, watched the talk, even listened to Tom Woodward’s Remix of the talk. I took notes on Gardener’s thoughts and let them stew. I thought of writing a traditional […]

  10. […] there was the remix of Gardner Campbell’s Bag of Gold, then it was amazing digital story telling: Until that Moment, and now, #ds106 radio have been […]

  11. […] the kind the maybe the gold rush would use to filter between gold and dirt or what they use for compost to filter between nourishing earth and waste and the box […]

  12. […] Representations of highlights Tom Woodward “Bag of Gold” audio remix jan 11 20011 http://bionicteaching.com/?p=1811 […]

  13. […] of gold” became a bit of a viral meme last year. e.g. Tim’s Kinetic Typography, Tom Woodward audio remix, Giulia Forsythe’s visual notes, Barbara Dieu’s video remox — in all of these, […]

  14. […] and musicality of Gardner Campbell’s voice. I’ve been listen to Tom Wordward’s remix A Bag of Gold « Bionic Teaching and used on Radio Edutalk a few times (that was a great idea). Gardner Campbell is a powerful, […]

  15. […] I was interested enough in the language and poetic elements of Gardner’s talk that I opted remix it over Nas’s If I Ruled the World. You can see all kinds of responses to that post. That was empowering to me in a variety of ways […]

  16. […] bag-of-gold a brilliant remix of Gardner Campbell by Tom Woodward […]

  17. […] in which he — in an offhand manner — likened the potential of open learning to “bags of gold“ that people do not see as valuable. [3] Perhaps one day, open learning will be so […]

  18. […] and musicality of Gardner Campbell’s voice. I’ve been listen to Tom Wordward’s remix A Bag of Gold « Bionic Teaching and used on Radio Edutalk a few times (that was a great idea). Gardner Campbell is a powerful, […]

TrackBack URL